Scotch at Dan Murphy's, priced every Thursday. Lagavulin 16 and the ten bottles that define it.
Dan Murphy's · week of 2026-11-12

No article on Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey 700mL yet.
Thread · Compare the pair · from the Proper Twelve guy

1/Two whiskies at their own floor this week, and the shelf's oddest near-miss. Proper No. Twelve, the Irish blend, is $59. The Chita, Suntory's Japanese grain whisky, is $99, down from the $111 it carried in mid-September. Both plain shelf tickets, neither a members' deal.

2/Why they sit side by side: the profile model reads them as close kin. On make-up The Chita and Proper No. Twelve land in nearly the same spot, a cosine of 0.97. An Irish blend and a Japanese grain whisky, one broadly shared character.

3/The value model does not buy it. On worth-for-money it rates the two nowhere near each other. So take this as shared profile, not equal standing: different countries, different styles, one surprising overlap in the glass.

4/Put them together and the pair is $158, the cheapest the combination has been across the weeks I've tracked it; its usual sits near $168. Both bottles are at the low end of their own range right now. A bundle, if you want the two.

What they say about Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey 700mL
(no matched reviews)
the eight most distinctive words in its reviews, largest first

Price history13-week window ending 2026-11-12

505663697566.9966.9966.9966.9966.9966.9966.9958.9566.9966.9966.9963.9963.9908-2008-2709-0309-1009-1709-2410-0110-0810-1510-2210-2911-0511-12list ── · member ┈ · ○ carried · ◎ shelf-checked
Per standard drink $2.53 · 22.1 standard drinks in the bottle · #5 of 28 in Ireland
slot08-2008-2709-0309-1009-1709-2410-0110-0810-1510-2210-2911-0511-12
list / member66.99
observed
66.99
observed
66.99
observed
66.99
m 59.00
observed
66.99
m 59.00
observed
66.99
m 59.00
observed
66.99
m 59.00
observed
58.95
observed
66.99
observed
66.99
observed
66.99
observed
63.99
m 56.00
observed
63.99
m 56.00
observed
basismeanmediansdminmaxrangecvse meanlatestown-range pctl
list65.9166.992.3758.9566.998.043.6%0.6663.9923
member62.2259.004.7156.0066.9910.997.6%1.3156.0015
momentsm1 meanm2 varm3 skewm4 ex-kurt95% band of the mean
list65.915.62-2.56.4864.6 – 67.2
n = 13 priced of 13 window slots (carried weeks excluded from the statistics; the 13th slot lands 2026-10-29). Skew and kurtosis print at n ≥ 8, the fit's own G. Source: the .normalised.csv sidecars, list basis with member where it differed.
Its ten nearest, through this bottle's cohort
#candidatepriceCEARPprice − CEARP
1Tullamore Dew Irish Whiskey 700mL$62.99$58.30+4.69
2Powers Three Swallows Whiskey 700mL$78.99$57.68+21.31
3Teeling Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey 700mL$96.99$53.25+43.74
4Proper No. Twelve Irish Whiskey 1L$63.69$50.55+13.14
5Dubliner Irish Whiskey 700mL$72.99$50.46+22.53
6Glen Moray Classic Port Cask Single Malt Scotch Whisky 700mL$71.99$50.31+21.68
7Glen Moray Classic Single Malt Scotch Whisky 1L$62.99$50.31+12.68
8Glen Moray Classic Single Malt Scotch Whisky 700mL$59.00$50.31+8.69
9Glen Moray Peated Single Malt Scotch Whisky 700mL$71.99$50.31+21.68
10Glen Moray Sherry Cask Single Malt Scotch Whisky 700mL$71.99$50.31+21.68